JEVONS PARADOX Jevons Paradox

JEVONS PARADOX

• The AI Situation: Recently, a Chinese AI company named DeepSeek developed a chatbot that costs much less than the ones from American companies.
• This caused a drop in stock prices for U.S. tech companies.
• Satya Nadella’s View: Microsoft’s CEO, Satya Nadella, took a positive outlook on this situation.
• He pointed to Jevons Paradox, a 160-year-old idea from economics, to explain why this could still be a good thing for the industry.
• According to Nadella, as AI becomes more affordable and efficient, it will become more widely used, leading to even greater demand for it.

WHAT IS JEVONS PARADOX?

What It Means: Jevons Paradox is a concept that says: When a resource becomes more efficient, people tend to use more of it instead of less.

• The Original Example: In the 19th century, England was concerned about running out of coal, which powered the economy.
• At that time, economist William Stanley Jevons argued that making coal-burning technologies more efficient wouldn’t reduce coal use.
• In fact, it would increase it because cheaper coal-powered technologies would create more demand, leading to more coal being used, not less.
• The Paradox: Instead of using less coal, more efficient use of coal meant lower prices and more demand for things like factories, engines, and machines that ran on coal.

JEVONS PARADOX IN TODAY’S WORLD

How It Relates to Modern Technology:

• • Energy Efficiency: In modern times, Jevons Paradox is often used to explain how energy-efficient technologies might fail to reduce energy use. For example:
    • Fuel-Efficient Cars: If cars use less fuel, it becomes cheaper to drive.
    • This might lead people to drive more or buy more cars, which could actually increase fuel consumption.
    • Energy-Efficient Appliances: If refrigerators become more efficient, people might use them more or buy more of them, leading to higher energy consumption.

HOW DOES IT APPLY TO AI?

• AI Becoming Cheaper: Now, some people, like Satya Nadella, believe that Jevons Paradox might also apply to AI.
• As AI becomes cheaper and more efficient, it could lead to an explosion of demand for AI technology.
• In other words, despite competition from companies like DeepSeek, the growing efficiency of AI could actually lead to more profits for companies like Microsoft.
• AI’s Impact on Jobs: Some economists, like Erik Brynjolfsson, argue that as AI improves worker productivity, it could create more demand for human workers, rather than replacing them.
• This is similar to what happened when airplanes became more efficient.
• Even though jets allowed pilots to travel more miles, the increased demand for air travel meant more pilots were needed, not fewer.

FOR AI TO CAUSE JEVONS PARADOX IN JOBS, THESE THREE THINGS MUST HAPPEN

1. Increased Productivity: AI must actually make workers more productive, helping them do their tasks faster or better.

2. Lower Costs: The increased productivity must lead to lower costs for services or goods.

a. This could happen because AI can make work more efficient.

3. Greater Demand: As things become cheaper, more people must want them.

a. This would mean more demand for the service, similar to how cheaper coal-powered machines led to more coal being used in the 19th century.

CHALLENGES FOR AI’s EFFECT ON JOBS

• Uncertainty: We don’t yet know if AI will really increase productivity in all industries.
• In some cases, AI could completely replace human workers, leading to job losses instead of job growth.
• Demand Must Increase: For AI to create jobs, demand for AI-powered services must grow rapidly.
• For example, in farming, while technology has made food production much more efficient, food demand hasn’t increased enough to keep many farmers employed.

REAL LIFE EXAMPLES OF TECHNOLOGY REPLACING JOBS

• Agriculture Example: Many years ago, technologies like tractors helped farmers become much more productive.
• But even though farmers could produce food more efficiently, the demand for food didn’t grow quickly enough to need as many farmers.
• As a result, the number of farmers has drastically dropped over time.
• Brynjolfsson View: Despite job losses in sectors like agriculture, technology has, on the whole, created more jobs in other areas over time.
• For example, computers and spreadsheets made office work much more efficient, but they also opened the door to new jobs in technology, marketing, and other industries.

WHAT COULD THE FUTURE OF JOBS AND AI LOOK LIKE

• Unpredictability: It’s very difficult to predict exactly how AI will change the job market.
• For instance, Jevons was wrong when he predicted that England would run out of coal, which shows how difficult it is to make long-term predictions.
• Positive Change? While no one knows for sure, some economists believe that AI will lead to a Jevons Paradox effect in certain jobs.
• This means that as workers get more efficient with AI tools, demand for their work could grow, leading to more jobs and better wages.

CONCLUSION

AI’s Impact: The idea of Jevons Paradox suggests that, as AI becomes more affordable and efficient, it could create more demand for AI technology and even for human workers in certain occupations. But, there’s still a lot of uncertainty. In some cases, AI might replace jobs entirely, while in others, it might increase productivity and open up more opportunities. We don’t know yet how things will play out.

Note: Connect with Vajirao & Reddy Institute to keep yourself updated with latest UPSC Current Affairs in English.

Note: We upload Current Affairs Except Sunday.